FAIFA Appeals to PM to withdraw COTPA Amendment Bill as it will impair the livelihoods of Indian Tobacco Farmers
- Proposed bill will boost the illegal cigarette trade in India and will severely impact the demand for home grown tobacco and earnings of Indian farmers
- Rising smuggled and illicit cigarettes markets causing loss in excess of Rs 1300 crore every year to India’s FCV Tobacco Grower
- Requests not to get influenced by the international NGO’s who are misrepresenting facts to promote the interest of vested groups
In the last few years, the Government has imposed harsh tobacco regulations such as increasing the size of pictorial warnings, imposing punitive taxation on Cigarettes with the tax burden more than trebling since 2012-13 and has even withdrawn export benefits. All these are leading to adverse consequences on livelihood of crores of Indians without providing any alternatives livelihood opportunities or help to farmers who cannot grow any other equally remunerative crop in the dry and arid regions they reside in.
Presently, India has become the 4th largest and fastest growing illicit cigarette market in the world with illicit cigarettes representing 1/4th of the cigarette market. In the last one-and-a-half-decade illicit cigarette market in India has doubled from a level of 13.5 billion sticks in 2006 to 28 billion sticks in 2019. Illegal cigarettes do not use locally grown tobaccos and hence, an increase in illegal trade impacts the livelihood of tobacco farmers in the country as demand for domestic tobaccos reduces further. FCV farming community has lost more than Rs.6,000 crores over the last 7 years due to drop in off take of their produce. The growing illicit cigarette trade is not only affecting the legal cigarette industry and farmer incomes but is also affecting government revenues.
Moreover, India has a unique pattern of tobacco consumption and cigarettes are the smallest component of tobacco consumption in India and constitute only 9% of tobacco use. Over the last three decades, the legal cigarettes’ share of total tobacco consumption in India has declined from 21% in 1981-82 to 9% in 2019-20. During the same period the overall tobacco consumption in the country has increased by 46%. The legal market for tobacco being excessively regulated has not in any way reduced the demand for tobacco products but has only caused a shift in consumption from legal to illegal duty evaded cigarettes and tax-evaded cheaper products.
Demanding withdrawal of the bill, Mr. Javare Gowda, President, Federation of All India Farmer Associations (FAIFA), said, “These harsh amendments that have been proposed will terrorise retailers and traders and they would not want to engage in the sale of legal cigarettes. As a result, criminal syndicates who have been pushing illegal tobacco will gain ground and will flood the Indian market with illicit cigarettes. Such illicit cigarettes may be of bad quality and will certainly not follow any of the regulations in force in India. Even currently illegal tobacco product packages do not carry the statutory warning. Since these illicit cigarettes do not use domestically grown tobaccos produced by Indian farmers, the result would be loss of earnings and livelihood of millions of tobacco farmers who are dependent on the crop in the country.”
Mr. Murali Babu, General Secretary, Federation of All India Farmer Associations (FAIFA), said, “We have noted that in the Amendment Bill all the provisions of the FCTC are being given effect to in full force and in some cases more than as required by FCTC. However, there still has been no talk or action taken regarding the actual problems that the tobacco farmers are going to face due to these proposed stringent laws. We PM to bring to light this anomaly and the direct impact such stringent laws are going to have on the members of this Federation and other tobacco farmers.”
India is the second largest producer of tobacco in the world and a large exporter. Tobacco is cultivated in 13 States in the country providing livelihood to 4.57 crore people, that includes lakhs of farmers, labourers, poor rural population and tribals and their families. There is no other country in the world like India which has a huge dependence on the tobacco crop for livelihood.
The FCTC keeps harping that its provisions in no way intend to bring harm to tobacco farmers in anyway and viable alternatives are being looked at so that tobacco farmers can make the switch to alternate crops. However, in reality the FCTC or any of the non-governmental organisations with vested interests have provided no alternative or solution to the tobacco farmer. All the material or actions by FCTC on the plight of tobacco farmers are mere ideas without any footing in reality, especially of the realities of a country like India where unemployment and situation of farmers are already under stress.
Yashwanth Chidipothu, National Spokesperson, Federation of All India Farmer Associations (FAIFA), said, “We believe that our government has been misled by bodies with vested interests. We urge the government to investigate the real agenda of tobacco control activists and NGOs who are promoting a false propaganda and have initiated litigation in various fora to disrupt the legal trade of tobacco products.”
The FCV farming community appeals to the policy makers to pay attention to the extreme pain and injury that is being faced by the tobacco farmers and do not bring any amendment which will precipitate the crisis going forward.